26.2.2005
News

State aid regarding construction of infrastructure available to public

Judgment of the Court of First Instance in Valmont Nederland BV v Commission (T-274/01) of 16 September 2004 (Official Journal of the European Union C 244 of 1 October 2004)

The decision of the Court of First Instance (the “CFI”) provides additional guidance on state aid rules applicable to compensation of private operators for services of general economic interest.

The case involved a Dutch company, the claimant in the current proceedings, which purchased land from local authorities for commercial purposes. Later on, the company entered into an informal agreement with the authorities under which the former would build on the premises publicly available parking facilities.

At a further stage, the European Commission found that the purchase price of the land at issue was lower than its market price and thus the transaction might have involved some state aid. The Commission acknowledged that other operators were also able to use the parking facilities arranged at the premises free of charge, including related services such as protection against thefts, warehousing or unloading. However, the claimant still had the primary right to use the estate, hence receiving support from public funds.

Based on these facts, the Commission decided that, whereas half of the financial support received by the claimant by virtue of the reduced purchase price was effectively forwarded to other users of the parking facilities, the remaining proportion benefited only the claimant and hence qualified as operating state aid. Having found no specific circumstances to justify the award of the state aid, the Commission declared it unlawful and requested its recovery by the Dutch authorities.

The CFI rejected the assessment of the Commission as arbitrary and based on insufficient analysis of the facts of the case. The CFI indicated that operators other than the claimant were able to continuously use the latter’s premises for no consideration whatsoever. According to the CFI, the claimant was, therefore, providing services in the general economic interest. In accordance with the well-established case law of the European Community courts, claimant was consequently entitled to appropriate compensation.

The Commission was under the duty to assess to what extent the support received by the claimant might have reflected such due compensation. Therefore, the findings of the Commission that precisely half of the support constituted unlawful state aid was, given lack of sufficient evidence, arbitrary and unfounded.

As the result, the CFI annulled the Commission’s Decision on the State aid implemented by the Netherlands in favour of Valmont Nederland BV.

Other articles

20.6.2025
News

KŠB advised the seller on the sale of mcePharma to the Brenntag Group

The KŠB team, consisting of Vlastimil Pihera, Jakub Porod, and Dominika Bazalová, provided legal advice to the seller, Mr. Ivan Mikeš, in connection with the sale of 100% of the shares in mcePharma to the international Brenntag Group, a global leader in the distribution of chemicals and ingredients.
18.6.2025
News

KŠB Provided Legal Advisory in the Sale of ARETE Park Rokycany II to the REICO LONG LEASE Fund

Jiří Horník, Jakub Porod, and Yelizaveta Volodina assisted the ARETE group in the sale of the premium logistics complex ARETE Park Rokycany II. The buyer is the REICO LONG LEASE fund, managed by REICO Erste Asset Management. The fund primarily invests in logistics, industrial, retail, office, and other commercial properties, mainly in the Central European region.
17.6.2025
News

KŠB and Smetanova Litomyšl – a partnership with impact

Last weekend, as partners of the Smetanova Litomyšl festival, we had the honour of attending the opening concert of the festival’s 67th edition, featuring the Czech Philharmonic conducted by Jakub Hrůša and the exceptional Norwegian violinist Vilde Frang.